Pap smears or self-swabs in Maryland
At a gynecologist’s office, the routine is familiar to many: change into a disposable gown, lie back on the exam table, place your feet in stirrups, and wait as the doctor inserts a speculum, a metal instrument used to widen the vaginal walls, to collect a sample of cervical cells using a long swab.
This process is part of a Pap test, a screening tool designed to detect cervical cancer. Each year, nearly 14,000 American women are diagnosed with the disease, and about 4,400 die from it, according to the American Cancer Society (ACS). Those numbers might seem relatively low, largely thanks to widespread Pap testing, which helps detect and treat precancerous changes early. Globally, however, cervical cancer remains the fourth most common cancer among women, per the World Health Organization.
Despite its life-saving potential, the Pap test can be physically uncomfortable and emotionally distressing for many. For some, especially those with a history of trauma or certain medical conditions, the experience is particularly invasive. This discomfort may contribute to missed screenings, and that’s a concern. While rates of early-stage cervical cancer have declined, rates of advanced-stage disease have not improved across any demographic in the past two decades, according to 2023 ACS data.
A Promising Alternative: Self-Swab HPV Testing
A new FDA-approved alternative, introduced in mid-2024, offers a more comfortable option. Instead of a traditional pelvic exam, women can now use a self-swab test in their doctor’s office to collect a sample themselves, no stirrups or speculum required. The collected sample is then tested for human papillomavirus (HPV), the virus responsible for more than 95% of cervical cancer cases.
This test represents a significant advancement in screening technology. According to some doctors, the new method can focus on collecting cells from the vaginal wall which can still be effective for HPV detection, but far less invasive.
How the Self-Swab Test Works
While the self-swab test increases autonomy, it’s not yet entirely private. The procedure is done in a clinical setting, often with a clinician providing guidance. The woman is instructed to part the labia, insert a plastic swab about the size of a pen, gently rub it along the vaginal walls, then remove it. The swab is placed in a vial and sent to a lab for analysis.
Whether the clinician is present during the procedure is still under discussion. Many practitioners assume it’s done in private, similar to providing a urine sample, though the patient typically consults with a healthcare provider beforehand for instructions.
A Shift in Cervical Cancer Screening Strategy
Traditionally, the Pap test was the gold standard for detecting abnormal cervical cells. But more recently, the same sample has been used to test for HPV, which is more predictive of cervical cancer risk. Currently, both Pap and HPV tests are performed from the same sample. However, there’s a shift toward an "HPV-first" approach, screening for the virus initially, and only following up with a Pap test if HPV is detected. This more targeted approach could reduce unnecessary exams and interventions.
Benefits of the Self-Swab Method
The self-swab option offers several key advantages:
Greater comfort: Women who find pelvic exams painful—whether due to trauma, medical history, or conditions like vaginal atrophy—may find self-swabbing less distressing. “It gives women the chance to be in control,” Dr. Alimena says.
Comparable accuracy: Early studies suggest that self-swab HPV testing is just as effective at identifying who needs further cervical screening. Ongoing national research aims to confirm this on a broader scale.
Improved access and equity: Making screening less invasive could encourage more women to get tested, especially those in underserved communities. Black women, for example, face a 30% higher risk of cervical cancer and are 60% more likely to die from it. Meanwhile, nearly 25% of eligible women in the U.S. are overdue for screening, according to the National Cancer Institute.
What About Risks?
There are minimal downsides to self-swabbing. The swabs are designed to be soft and safe, and there’s no evidence they cause harm when used as directed. That said, some women may prefer a traditional clinician-performed Pap test, especially those with previous abnormal results who require close monitoring.
Looking Ahead: At-Home HPV Testing
The current self-swab method must still be done in a doctor’s office. However, home-based versions are on the horizon. Much like home colon cancer screening kits, women would collect a sample themselves, then mail it to a lab for analysis. The FDA is still evaluating home testing kits, and careful instructions and follow-up protocols will be crucial.
Staying Proactive: Prevention Tips
While new technology helps, prevention remains key. Here are a few recommendations:
Get vaccinated: The HPV vaccine is recommended for children ages 9–12, and adults up to age 45 may still be eligible.
Keep screening: Women should start cervical cancer screening in their 20s and continue through at least age 65. Some may need to continue beyond that if they’ve had prior abnormal Pap results.
Pap Smear Screenings in Bowie
Bowie Internal Medicine is committed to treating any conditions you may have, as well as preventing further health complications through preventative care. For more information about managing your headaches, pleasecontact our office to schedule an appointment or ask any questions.